One clue might be that
alternative medicine has always been very popular in the United States.
Although many aspects may appear to be of recent vintage, the truth of
the matter is that there is very little that doesn’t have old roots.
This background of alternative medicine, and especially its rocky
relationship with orthodox, mainstream medicine, is the topic of the
book
Nature Cures by James C. Whorton, Professor of the History of Medicine in the University of Washington School of Medicine.
One factor in the popularity of alternative medicine may be
found in its very religious nature. There are a number of
characteristics of just about all forms of alternative medicine which
are similar to those found in most religions:
The importance of this philosophical foundation shared by
all systems of alternative medicine can hardly be overstated. When the
leaders of naturopathy today aver that their medicine is “more than
simply a health care system; it is a way of life,” they are stating
that they think of human beings, their relation to the environment, and
their responses to environment and therapy in fundamentally different
ways than mainstream physicians do.”
[...]
“Nature has been worshipped not
just as the strongest therapy but also as the most effective
prevention. Indeed, all alternative systems have subscribed to the
philosophy that natural physiological integrity, maintained through
proper diet, adequate rest, and other correct habits of life, is the
only
sure resistance to disease agents. This position was advanced with
particular ardor in the late nineteenth century, in response to
[mainstream doctors’] emphasis on microoganisms as the cause of most
illness. In the terse summation of a physio-medical doctor, the “best
antiseptic” was not the chemical drugs prescribed so exuberantly by MDs
but “vital force.””
“Identification of the body’s resisting power as vital force
points to another essential component of [alternative medicine]:
vitalism, or the belief that the human body is activated and directed
by a life force that is unique to living organisms and that transcends
the laws of physics and chemistry used to account for the phenomena of
the inorganic world. ...it has been embraced as a repudiation of the
trend within orthodox medicine to reduce the body to physical and
chemical mechanisms.”
Not registered yet? We'll like you more if you do!